Bravehearts' Kilt Forum

Re: An extended family, united by with ties of blo

Posted By: gaullish (78.150.244.216)
Date: 5/13/08 18:04

In Response To: An extended family, united by with ties of blood, (Doc Hudson)

a common area of origin had NO bearing on what made a clan, and the scots would NOT have considered area of origin. It is irrelevant as all scots are from scotland.

a 16th to 17th 18th century clan chief would not have proclaimed an area of origin relevant because of course all of his clan would have been born and raised. I really do not think he would have held the future american and canadian descendants in much thought would he ????

"ties of a common history" I have an friend whos parents were italian immigrants, I have never heard him all himself a roman or legionnaire just because his parents were italian.

if all american desendants are part of a scottish clan, then maybe all italian desendants are roman legionaires and maybe all of the guys who work at my local kebab shop are part of the anceint order of hittites lol

Messages In This Thread

Border Tartans -- Will's Wat (dip-220-235-48-106.wa.westnet.com.au) -- 5/2/08 08:24

Re: Border Tartans -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/2/08 09:39

Re: Border Tartans -- Ancient Marshall (client.uk.hub.oup.com) -- 5/2/08 12:24

Re: Border Tartans -- Dave (78.146.201.70) -- 5/5/08 05:14

Re: Border Tartans -- Chris Webb (ppp-70-250-194-123.dsl.rcsntx.swbell.net) -- 5/5/08 18:19

Re: Border Tartans -- Will's Wat (dip-220-235-43-205.wa.westnet.com.au) -- 5/5/08 20:21

Re: Border Tartans -- Will's Wat (dip-220-235-43-205.wa.westnet.com.au) -- 5/5/08 20:24

Re: Border Tartans -- gaullish (78.150.244.216) -- 5/6/08 09:33

Re: Border Tartans -- Galician (sw01.verizon.com) -- 5/6/08 09:52

Save your fingers Galician! -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/7/08 17:00

Re: Save your fingers Galician! -- Chris Webb (ppp-70-255-245-139.dsl.rcsntx.swbell.net) -- 5/7/08 22:27

Wouldn't you just love to hear... -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/8/08 00:28

Re: Save your fingers Galician! -- gaullish (78.150.244.216) -- 5/10/08 14:29

Re: Save your fingers Galician! -- Chris Webb (ppp-70-246-56-49.dsl.rcsntx.swbell.net) -- 5/11/08 00:09

Way to go Chris!! -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/11/08 09:03

Re: Save your fingers Galician! -- bear@bearkilts.com (d207-216-165-123.bchsia.telus.net) -- 5/12/08 01:39

Bear, my point was -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/12/08 01:56

Re: clans and tartans -- Ancient Marshall (client.uk.hub.oup.com) -- 5/12/08 07:06

Re: clans and tartans -- gaullish (78.150.244.216) -- 5/12/08 08:22

Not all Scots agree with you gaullish -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/13/08 02:50

Re: Not all Scots agree with you gaullish -- gaullish (78.150.244.216) -- 5/13/08 10:02

An extended family, united by with ties of blood, -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/13/08 11:54

Re: An extended family, united by with ties of blo -- gaullish (78.150.244.216) -- 5/13/08 18:04

I guess things are different here in the States -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/13/08 18:53

Re: clans and tartans -- Ancient Marshall (client.uk.hub.oup.com) -- 5/16/08 10:17

Re: clans and tartans -- gaullish (78.150.244.216) -- 5/16/08 15:19

Re: clans and tartans -- phil (cache-los-aa03.proxy.aol.com) -- 5/30/08 15:13

Re: clans and tartans -- Rod (209.232.148.100) -- 5/30/08 17:53

Re: clans and tartans -- Chris Webb (ppp-70-253-43-200.dsl.rcsntx.swbell.net) -- 5/30/08 18:56

See, I told you you were wasting time and fingers -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/12/08 08:43

Re: See, I told you you were wasting time and fing -- binx (64.241.37.140) -- 5/12/08 20:57

I should nhave taken my own advise! ntd fing -- Doc Hudson (adsl-074-171-234-092.sip.jan.bellsouth.net) -- 5/14/08 02:53

Re: Border Tartans -- gaullish (78.150.244.216) -- 5/6/08 10:50

Re: Border Tartans -- gaullish (78.150.244.216) -- 5/6/08 10:54

Re: Border Tartans -- Andrew (ppp91-122-113-54.pppoe.avangarddsl.ru) -- 5/15/08 06:01